Was Jeff Kent the Right Choice for the Baseball Hall of Fame Induction in 2026?

Photo: Jeff Kent/BBHOF Newest Inductee/Getty Images

The Contemporary Era Committee recently cast their votes for the Baseball Hall of Fame candidates, sparking plenty of debate among fans and analysts alike. The big question on everyone’s mind was whether Don Mattingly or Dale Murphy would finally earn their spot in Cooperstown. Surprisingly, neither made the cut. Instead, Jeff Kent emerged as the sole inductee for 2026. This decision has stirred a lively conversation, especially between Shawn and Howie, who shared their thoughts on the selection and the candidates who didn’t make it. Let’s explore whether Jeff Kent was the right choice and what this means for the Hall of Fame.

Shawn and Howie’s discussion highlighted how the committee balances statistical achievements with intangibles like leadership and impact on the game. They also noted the challenge of comparing players across eras and positions, especially when offensive environments and defensive metrics have evolved.

Shawn and Howie debated how these players stack up against Kent and each other. They pointed out that Kent’s offensive production, especially his home run totals for a second baseman, gave him an edge. Yet, they acknowledged that some fans might have preferred a different candidate based on defensive prowess or leadership qualities.

Listen to the show here and let us know if you agree with Jeff Kent's induction in the comments section!

Listen on Buzzsprout:

Listen on iHeart Radio: